An AC motor runs on the alternating supply at the switchboard, 415 V three phase at 50 Hz is common on most Australian and New Zealand sites. A DC motor runs on direct current from a battery, a rectifier or a DC drive. That one difference sets the construction, the way speed is controlled and maintains the load. The AC induction motor has no brushes and no electrical connection to the rotor, so the only wearing parts are the bearings. A brushed DC motor passes its armature current through a commutator and carbon brushes, which wear and need inspection and ongoing maintenance. Almost every pump, fan, compressor and conveyor we supply across Australia and New Zealand runs on a three phase AC induction motor, with a variable speed drive (VSD) where the process requires speed control. DC motors remain in traction, battery powered plant and some older cranes, hoists and mills. Below is the AC vs DC motor comparison, with the figures that matter when you specify.
AC motors: induction, synchronous and wound rotor
Three phase current in the stator winding produces a magnetic field that rotates at synchronous speed, which is 1,500 rpm for a 4 Pole motor on 50 Hz. In a squirrel cage induction motor that induces field current in the rotor bars, and the two fields pull the rotor round at a slip of a few per cent below synchronous speed. Nothing touches the rotor except its bearings. A synchronous motor runs at synchronous speed with its own excited rotor field and is used on large compressors and mills where constant speed or power factor matters. A wound rotor induction motor brings the rotor winding out through slip rings for controlled high starting torque with lower starting current on mills and crushers.
Our low voltage stock is squirrel cage induction motors in two efficiency classes. The TECO MAXe3 Mining is the IE3 cast iron range: 0.18 kW to 450 kW in frames 63 to 355, Class H insulation with a Class B temperature rise, IP66. TECO Te3 is also an IE3 cast iron range: 0.55 kW to 500 kW in frames 80 to 400, Class F insulation with a Class B temperature rise, both meet AS/NZS MEPS and IEC 60034-30-1. On a VSD the MAXe3 and Te3 run variable torque loads such as centrifugal pumps and fans between 5 and 50 Hz without derating, and insulated bearings or shaft earthing are available where the drive installation calls for them. The TECO MAXeV4 is the IE4 Super Premium Efficiency range: 0.75 kW to 315 kW in frames 80 to 355L, Class H insulation with a Class B temperature rise, IP66 on every frame, 2, 4 and 6 Pole and S1 duty. It reaches IE4 with a standard squirrel cage rotor and no magnets, so it starts direct on line or runs on any VSD. Many other IE4 designs use permanent magnet or synchronous reluctance rotors and have to run on a drive.
Above 1,000 V we supply squirrel cage induction motors to bespoke design or as drop-in replacements, TEFC up to 11,000 V and TEAAC up to 13,800 V, for safe and hazardous areas.
DC motors: brushed and brushless
A DC motor produces torque from the current in a wound armature turning inside a stationary field, from field windings or permanent magnets. In a brushed motor a commutator and carbon brushes reverse the armature current as the rotor turns. The brushes wear, the commutator surface needs inspection and maintenance, and produces dust, which is why brushed DC machines dropped out of continuous industrial duty once AC drives became affordable. Speed follows armature voltage, so a DC drive gives fine speed control down to standstill with full torque. That is why DC held its place in cranes, hoists, traction and rolling mills for so long. A brushless DC motor moves the switching into electronics and puts permanent magnets on the rotor; it needs its own matched drive and is common in small machinery, fans and battery powered equipment.
DC motors are not part of the range we hold in Australia and New Zealand. When a site asks us to replace an old DC drive, the usual answer is an AC induction motor on a vector control VSD, which gives the same low speed torque without brushes, and the TECO ModShop fits the forced ventilation, encoder or special shaft the retrofit needs.
AC vs DC motor: comparison
| Factor | AC induction motor | DC motor |
|---|---|---|
| Supply | Three phase 415 V 50 Hz from the switchboard, or the output of a VSD; stock motors to 1,100 V to order, MV and HV ranges above that | Direct current from a battery, a rectifier or a DC drive |
| Speed control | Speed follows supply frequency; a VSD varies frequency and voltage, down to a few hertz on a vector drive | Speed follows armature voltage; field weakening extends it above base speed; fine control down to standstill |
| Starting | Direct on line, star-delta, soft starter or VSD; starting current and torque set by the method | Full torque from standstill through the DC drive |
| Maintenance | Bearings and grease; no brushes, no commutator; re-greasing while running from frame D200 on the MAXe3 and D180 on the Te3 | Brush wear, brush spring pressure, commutator condition, carbon dust, plus bearings (brushed); bearings and drive only (brushless) |
| Efficiency | Rated in IE classes to IEC 60034-30-1: MAXe3 IE3, Te3 IE3, MAXeV4 IE4; MEPS applies in Australia and New Zealand | No IE class applicable; brush and commutator losses on brushed machines; brushless designs are efficient but drive dependent |
| Typical applications | Pumps, fans, compressors, conveyors, crushers, mills, agitators, mixers, HVAC, water and wastewater, mining | Traction, battery powered plant, older cranes, hoists and rolling mills, small brushless machinery |
| What TECO supplies | MAXe3 Mining (IE3), Te3 (IE3) and MAXeV4 (IE4) from stock, hazardous area and MV/HV squirrel cage motors, plus the VSD and soft starter ranges | No DC motors; an AC motor and VSD package for DC retrofits |
AC or DC motor: which one for an industrial drive
Specify an AC induction motor unless the supply itself is DC. For a fixed speed duty, a TECO MAXe3, Te3 or TECO MAXeV4 direct on line or on a soft starter does the job. For speed control, put the same motor on a VSD: the drive sets the frequency, limits the starting current and gives the low speed torque that used to need a DC machine. Three checks go on the enquiry: the IP rating for the site (IP66 on the MAXe3 and MAXeV4), the ambient temperature against the rating, and whether the motor runs on a drive, so we fit shaft earthing or an insulated bearing where the installation calls for it. The full selection path is in our article on three phase induction motor selection; what the drive does is in what is a variable speed drive and on the variable speed drives page; the parts of the motor are in key components of an electric motor.
Send us the nameplate of the motor you are replacing, AC or DC, with the load and the site conditions through the Contact us page, and we come back with the AC motor and drive that fits. The full range of TECO electric motors is on this site.
AC vs DC motor FAQs
What is the difference between an AC and a DC motor?
An AC motor runs on alternating current and a DC motor on direct current, and that sets how each produces torque. An AC induction motor has no brushes and no connection to the rotor; a brushed DC motor needs a commutator and brushes to feed the armature. On an industrial site the AC induction motor is the standard choice, with a VSD where speed control is needed.
How does a DC motor work?
Current in the armature winding sits in a magnetic field and produces torque; the commutator and brushes reverse the current every half turn so the torque keeps the same direction. Speed rises with armature voltage, which is how a DC drive controls it. A brushless DC motor does the same switching electronically with magnets fitted on the rotor.
How does an AC induction motor work?
The three phase stator current creates a rotating magnetic field, which induces current in the rotor bars; the rotor follows the field at a slip of a few per cent. No brushes, no rotor connection, bearings are the only wearing parts. The TECO MAXe3, Te3 and TECO MAXeV4 are squirrel cage induction motors of this type.
Are AC or DC motors more efficient?
For industrial duty the AC induction motor, which is rated in IE classes: the TECO MAXeV4 is IE4 Super Premium Efficiency across 0.75 kW to 315 kW, the TECO MAXe3 is IE3 across 0.75 kW to 450 kW and the TECO Te3 is IE3 across 0.55 kW to 500 kW. Brushed DC motors carry brush and commutator losses and have no IE class. Brushless DC motors are efficient in small sizes but depend on their drive.
Which is better, an AC or a DC motor?
For pumps, fans, compressors, conveyors and most plant, an AC induction motor, because it has no brushes to maintain, suits IP66 enclosures and accepts any VSD. A DC motor still makes sense where the supply is a battery or where an existing DC drive and controls are staying in service.
Can a DC motor run on AC?
No, except for the universal motor used in hand tools and some appliances, which is a series wound brushed machine built for either. An industrial DC motor on an AC supply will not run and its windings will overheat. Replace it with an AC motor or feed it from a rectifier or DC drive.
Are electric car motors AC or DC?
The battery is DC, but almost all modern traction motors are AC, either permanent magnet synchronous or induction, fed by an inverter that converts the battery DC to three phase AC.